tv The Ed Show MSNBC June 1, 2011 1:00am-2:00am EDT
now it's time for "the ed show." have a good night. good evening everybody. welcome to "the ed show." i'm thomas roberts filling in for ed schultz. the house rejected a bill to raise the debt ceiling without cutting spending while republicans stand by paul ryan's medicare slashing budget plan, democrats say it should be off the table before the sides can come to any agreement. as ed would say let's get to work. over a barrel, washington could do something to lower gas prices immediately. senator bernie sanders tells us why they won't. >> they were required to do that in january. we are now in may and they have not yet done that. >> more republican recalls move ahead in wisconsin. we've got the latest details. buyer's remorse? voters who helped usher in a new class of republican governors wish they hadn't.
could it help president obama? and how will this help the president? >> oh, it would be a blast if they were this loud and if they smelled this good. i love that smell of the emissions. >> sarah palin's road show. she's got the bus but she's not telling anyone where it's heading, including fellow republicans. so today house republicans held a vote on whether to raise the nation's debt limit and they got their way, a big fat no to raising this country's debt ceiling without conditions attached to it. and according to furious democrats, republicans proved once again that they are willing to risk sending this country into default unless the budget is slashed and that includes the most contentious budget cutting issue of the moment, medicare. the vote was 318-97 against raising the debt ceiling without conditions. now if the debt ceiling is not raised by early august the country will go into default with catastrophic consequences. today's vote was set up by republicans to be a test vote requiring a two-thirds majority that had no chance of being reached, even 82 democrats voted
no to avoid a political trap. we'll have more on that for you in a moment. first though the dynamics of this fight are now very clear. the nation's debt ceiling must be raised but republicans have refused to do that without agreement on future cuts. those budget cuts are based on the ryan budget already passed by the republican controlled house and the ryan budget includes the medicare plan which would end medicare as we know it today. now, democrats were eager to portray the debt ceiling vote as further evidence that republicans will go to any lengths to slash medicare. >> this is about threatening to default on the full faith and credit of the united states unless we put into place the republican budget including their plan to end the medicare guarantee and to slash medicare benefits. that's what this is all about. they said, whoa. we're going to hold this whole thing up until we get our way.
>> house minority whip steny hoyer urged democrats to vote no with republicans even though he supported raising the debt ceiling. he said that republicans would try to use a yes vote against them. >> ladies and gentlemen, i'm going to vote no on this. we ought to vote for this. we ought to have a clean bill. and we ought to have both sides coming together and saying, america needs this for debts that we have incurred. it's a good demagoguey vote frankly and if we vote for it guess what? you're for raising the debt limit without any fiscal discipline. >> and then this from house minority leader nancy pelosi. >> but the fact is that what is happening on this floor is not serious. it's not serious but the subject it addresses is serious to stop this assault on medicare which is the basis for this legislation today. >> now the connection between the debt ceiling and ryan's medicare plan was becoming more evident even before today's
vote. from the senate republican leader mitch mcconnell who said this on sunday. >> to get my vote to raise the debt ceiling for whatever that's worth, my one vote, medicare will be a part of it. the details of that are yet to be negotiated. the president to his credit is at the table discussing with us the way in which you save medicare. >> democratic senator chuck schumer said republicans needed to take the ryan plan off the table in order to get bipartisan agreement on the debt ceiling. >> the only way we're going to come to an agreement on the budget and the debt ceiling is if senator mcconnell and his republican colleagues take the ryan plan off the table and take it off now. >> and house republican majority leader eric canter explained that once again when republicans say everything is on the table, they mean that all spending cuts
are on the table. >> everything is on the table. we've said as republicans we're not going to go for tax increases. i think the administration gets that. >> right. >> but we've also put everything on the table as far as cuts. >> you know, tomorrow morning president obama is scheduled to meet with house republicans over these very key issues. let's bring in the senior political reporter at the huffington post amanda, good to have you on with us. let's get straight to it. we know this was a test vote to test the waters but explain what republicans were trying to accomplish by doing this today. was it just show boating? >> well, first of all, it was to give some of their members, their more conservative members who were elected by tea party activists, some political cover. they can now go back to their districts and say, look. i didn't do it to raise the debt limit. and what we need is to compare this with spending cuts. if they have to eventually go ahead in their pressure to raise the debt limit with some spending cuts they could say this is what we had to do. i already voted against raising it. i didn't like it but we had to
do this. so it's some political cover but also meant to reinforce their message that we need to have spending cuts pared with the debt limit. they can say look a lot of democrats joined with us. >> here is where it becomes a game of chess. democrats were urged by congressman hoyer to vote no so since the measure had no chance of passing did he have a valid point or does it make the democrats look divided? >> he absolutely had a valid point. no one expected this to pass. i think the administration would have liked it to pass but no one expected it to so he was just telling his members, look. you're going to have to go back to your districts. they're going to try to air attack ads so don't give them ammunition. republicans will try to use it to their advantage either way. but i think hoyer was wise in telling his members vote how you want to. if you don't want to vote against it, if you want to vote against it, go ahead. >> there are these ongoing talks between the white house and congressional leaders over all of this. are democrats worried that the white house will actually relent, maybe agree to some of these medicare cuts? >> i think that's a constant worry. i mean, even right after this vote there were some republicans saying, look. this strengthens our case.
the entitlement including medicare need to be on the table and taken seriously. there are a lot of progressive activists who are very worried that medicare is on the table in these budget talks. they are trying to cut $1 trillion in spending. you don't get there just by pid ling at the edges with npr and planned parenthood. i think there is a lot of concern this will happen and a lot of democrats would like to see some tax raises. >> amanda, how troubling is it to democrats that no matter what republicans have been very successful at being able to tie the debt ceiling to these severe budget cuts? >> well, i think this is -- i think this is very troubling to democrats. again, i think democrats would like to see, you know, you can have some spending cuts but you also need to raise revenue and that's something when eric canter says everything is on the table he means everything in terms of spending cuts. he doesn't actually mean tax
increases. and that's where a lot of democrats are saying, look. let's cut subsidies for oil companies. let's maybe raise taxes on the wealthiest but that is something republicans are saying we don't really want to do. >> amanda, great to see you tonight. thanks. >> thank you. let's turn now to the founder and chief education officer of movement vision.org. sally, good to have you. has there been anything like this before when we talked about the debt ceiling that's been raised historically over and over again by whether or not we're led by a democrat or whether or not we're led by a republican, but in an instance like this where it's being tied so dramatically to the spending cuts, by republicans? >> no. the answer is no. we are at a new level of political threat here. the republicans are using this for political theater. yeah there's always been some gamesmanship over this. it is a political issue. they play football with it. but this time the republicans are seriously threatening to ruin the future of our economy and the future of the middle class. this is, let's be very clear,
ideological terrorism. they are threatening to blow up our nation's economy and our future for the sake of some political point. >> i know you said it seems like football but it's more like pot potato watching this go on in washington, d.c. and kicking it around but you've written about what you call the hype surrounding u.s. debt. are we part of that in our coverage? >> i'm not going to point fingers at you thomas. >> all right. >> i'll let you off the hook until i go back and review it later. here's the thing. this is a manufactured crisis. yes, can debt be a problem? are there problems with medicare, are reforms needed? yes. this is largely a manufactured crisis that is then being exploited by republicans in order to cram down our throats a long held ideological agenda to kill government and to kill everything that's made america work for the middle class and the poor. so the truth is, at this moment in time, look. businesses are sitting on record
capital, record levels of capital that they're not spending. government is the spender of last resort. the thing i wrote about was the fact that in the private sector successful businesses have two times, three times, sometimes 14, 15 times more debt-to-income ratios than the government. why is it okay for them and not us? >> sally, do you think the american public is adequately getting and being able to take stock of what's going on here to realize what's actually at stake? >> you know, yes and no. what's encouraging is the american public opposes cuts to medicare. sees through some of the smoke screen, this red herring the republicans are trying to create and exploit. but, unfortunately, americans also believe that we have a real debt problem and the fact is you grow the economy, you fix the economy, you invest in our future. yes, using debt today you pay down that debt tomorrow and if republicans were really, really serious about the deficit, then half of their budget or i'm sorry 70% of their budget plan wouldn't be going to more tax
cuts for the rich. they'd actually be lowering the deficit which their plan doesn't do. >> when we talk about this individually we talk about the fact that okay. at home we got to live by it. if we don't got it we don't spend it. in talking about this and what it is doing for our government does this set a terrible precedent for what could happen in the future twle comes to the debt ceiling and also the economy globally? because if we're not paying off our debts that sends a really bad message internationally. >> it was ronald reagan in 1987 who said that defaulting on federal debt would be unthinkable. that was reagan. of course that was a very different republican party than we have now. the sort of ideological terrorists who are taking our government and economy hostage. so, yeah. i mean, it is a different situation but we have to remember that family budget metaphor is the wrong metaphor to be playing with. we should be thinking about the consequences of defaulting on your mortgage. they're atrocious. you lose your home. you lose your whole family's way of life and existence. this will -- we will lose standing in the world, our
children's future will not continue to go on. but moreover if the republicans get their way and slash government by 3/4 as they're planning to do with nondiscretionary spending our kids also won't have the life that america has come to know. >> we have until august 2nd. do you think we'll be talking about this up until the very last minute? >> i sure hope not. i really hope the reasonable majority of americans including the reasonable majority of republicans can bring some sense to washington. >> all right. you brought some sense to our set tonight. great to have you here. thanks for your time. from move on vision.org. so if supply and demand are driving gas prices up why do prices drop during one of the heaviest travel weekends of the year? and three more republicans will have to face the voters of wisconsin this summer to answer for the vote, their vote to strip workers' rights in the birth place of collective bargaining. back with more after this. he recommended citracal. it's different -- it's calcium citrate, so it can be absorbed with or without food. also available in small, easy-to-swallow petites.
citracal. ♪ [ female announcer ] mini, meet berries. introducing new kellogg's frosted mini-wheats with a touch of fruit in the middle. helloooooo fruit in the middle. this past year alone fruit in the middle. there was a 93% increase in cyber attacks. in financial transactions... on devices... in social interactions... and applications in the cloud. some companies are worried. some, not so much. thanks to a network that secures it all and knows what to keep in, and what to keep out. outsmart the threats. see how at cisco.com cisco.
from some pretty heavy hitters. god himself has now apparently weighed in. >> every decision i make i pray about as does my husband and i can tell you, yes, i've had that calling and that tugging on my heart that this is the right thing to do. and because it's such a momentous decision, not only for myself, my husband, and our 28 children, it is a momentous children what ideas will i bring to bear? >> the congresswoman still seems to be working on those ideas, when it comes to whether president bachmann would sign paul ryan's medicare plan into law. she voted for the bill but then said her support came with an asterisk. this morning bachmann was asked about her position. >> the asterisk is that people don't realize this is about people who are 55 and under. i don't want a 78-year-old woman to think that medicare is going to be pulled out from under her because it won't. >> if you were president you would sign the congressman's plan into law?
>> well, the other portion that i think is very important is that in the middle of dealing with all insurance, the numbers, we can't forget humanity. >> i understand that but does that mean you would sign the bill or not? >> well, i think some version of this bill because paul is right. we have to sustain medicare. we can't let it just go away for senior citizens. >> for now bachmann is keeping her 2012 decision to herself. she says she is going to make her announcement in iowa sometime in june. meanwhile, michele bachmann's fellow tea party er ier was asked about her 2012 plans. that is not stopping her from breathing in all that is good about america. more on palin's patriotic bus tour coming up. [ man ] at ge capital, we're out there every day with clients like jetblue -- financing their fleet, sharing our expertise, and working with people who are changing the face of business in america. after 25 years in the aviation business, i kind of feel like if you're not having fun at what you do,
then you've got the wrong job. my landing was better than yours. no, it wasn't. yes, it was. was not. yes, it was. what do you think? take one of the big ones out? nah. ♪ just don't feel like they used to. are you one of them? remember when you had more energy for 18 holes with your buddies. more passion for the one ya love. more fun with your family and friends. it could be a treatable condition called low testosterone or low t. come on, stop living in the shadows. you've got a life to live. [ male announcer ] so don't blame it on aging. talk to your doctor and go to isitlowt.com to find out more.
so memorial day is traditionally a high travel holiday on the roads but a funny thing happened at the gas pump this weekend. take a look. here is the national average price for a gallon of regular gasoline today. $3.78. the average price yesterday, memorial day, a half cent higher. one week ago it was over $3.82. and a month ago more than $3.94. so based on supply and demand economics, the price should have gotten higher over the busy memorial day weekend but instead the price has gone down. steadily over the past month. some lawmakers are turning their attention away from supply and demand and toward commodity speculation to explain the high cost of oil. several senators met last week with gary gensler the chairman of the commodities futures trading commission to ask why his agency is not regulating oil speculation. senator bernie sanders led the charge. >> in the dodd/frank financial reform bill, the cftc was
required, not asked, required to deal with speculation. they were required to do that in january. we are now in may and they have not yet done that. >> senator sanders is asking president obama to get tough on the cftc. in a letter to the president last month the senator wrote i urge you to make it clear to the cftc that they must obey the law and establish strong oil speculation limits as soon as possible. i would also urge you to ask for the immediate resignation of any cftc commissioner who refuses to obey the law and nominate someone else who will. now according to a senate aide, senators asked chairman gensler to implement emergency powers to crack down on oil speculators but he declined to do so. we asked the cftc why it won't use these emergency powers but a
spokesman did not give us an answer in time for this broadcast tonight. joining me now by phone is senator bernie sanders of vermont. it's good to speak with you once again. >> good to be with you. >> you've said the cftc is violating the law and air calling for the resignation of its members. are your requests falling on deaf ears? do you think you're going to get anywhere with that request? >> well, i think we will. when you have the ceo of exxon mobil telling us that perhaps 40% of the price of oil today is due to speculation, when you have goldman sachs itself and they are major speculators suggesting that the price of oil has 20% effect because of speculation, we recently learned that in 2008 when we also had an oil spike the saudi arabian government told the u.s. government, told bush administration, that there was not a need for more oil production, that the reason the prices were so high was because of speculation. when you have all of that, i think the answer is that we have
got to crack down on speculators who control now about 70% of the oil futures market. >> senator, you asked chairman gensler to use emergency powers though on oil speculation back in 2009. this is after that 2008 oil spike that you just talked about. so do you know why the cftc won't use these powers if they will cause the price of oil to drop and do so considerably? >> well, there are two issues. the chairman himself has in my view the power to -- has the capability to use emergency powers. he refuses to do that. i guess it's too bold an action for him. my understanding is they think they don't have the votes. there are five people on the commission. they only have two votes in order to begin to address the issue. my view is they have got to raise the sense of urgency. the president has got to become involved in this issue. but the vast majority of the people believe this has something to do with supply and demand. it doesn't.
more supply less demand. we have required the cftc to act. they're not doing it. the president must demand that they do that. if they don't do it those guys should leave office. other people should assume that position and fulfill what the law requires. >> sir, we've been told by a senate source that chairman gensler said as much as 85% of trading in the energy market is done by speculators and yet he also said that he doesn't know if speculation is driving prices. so in your mind how did those two statements square with one another? >> they're absurd. i think when you have over 80% of the oil futures market controlled by speculators, these are the wall street guys who do not use the product, they're not in the airline business. they're not in the trucking business. they're not in the fuel business. they are simply driving up prices to suggest on the part of mr. gensler that he doesn't know what the prices are going up or down because of the speculation to me is a totally absurd
remark. >> so instead of all of us depending on the cftc why can't we depend on you guys because the bill to curb energy speculation passed in 2008 by a vote of 402-19 so why isn't there broad bipartisan support for such a bill any longer? >> that is a very good idea and there may well be. i think what the general feeling was that as a result of dodd/frank the wall street reform act these guys were required to act. we thought that was good enough. okay. they did not act. what's plan b? plan b i believe is that the congress has got to bring forth legislation to force them to act. >> if we see the prices going down, though, modestly as we're seeing right now, sir, does it take the heat off just a bit? >> it shouldn't because the whole issue, it really shouldn't. there has been extraordinary volatility over the last three years of oil prices. gone up, gone down, gone up. this is not doing -- this is not a result of supply and demand.
this is an issue we have to get a handle on or else it will simply keep repeating itself. when oil in my state, which is a rural state, people travel long distances to work, this is really taking a bite out of their paycheck. this is an issue affecting millions of working people. it is affecting our entire economy. we have to deal with it now and make sure it doesn't happen again and again in the future. >> is this something that has president obama's attention? >> he has talked about it occasionally but i don't think with the urgency it requires. no. i think if the president got up and said we're going to deal with this speculation now and deal with it tomorrow that would happen. he has not done that. >> what would bring the urgency, the spike we saw in '08? >> you know, when gas is at $3.82 a gallon or over $4 a gallon in many parts of the country i think that is a sense of urgency. when we know this is threatening, when the price of oil is threatening the fragile recovery that we're in right now, this is -- requires a sense of urgency. i wish the president was
stronger on this issue. >> senator bernie sanders from vermont, sir, always good to talk to you. thanks for joining us tonight. >> thank you. florida governor rick scott may be america's most unpopular governor. new polls show increased displeasure with republican governors across the country. we'll explore that. and sarah palin, all american bus tour swinging by historic sites like mount vernon, the liberty bell, gettysburg, and of course trump tower. so i took my heartburn pill and some antacids. we're having mexican tonight, so another pill then? unless we eat later, then pill later? if i get a snack now, pill now? skip the snack, pill later... late dinner, pill now? aghh i've got heartburn in my head.
[ male announcer ] stop the madness. take prilosec otc for frequent heartburn. one pill a day. twenty-four hours. zero heartburn. no heartburn in the first place. great. [ male announcer ] use as directed for 14 days. vietnam, 1967. i got mine in iraq, 2003. u.s.a.a. auto insurance is often handed down from generation to generation, because it offers a superior level of protection and because u.s.a.a.'s commitment to serve the military, veterans, and their families is without equal. begin your legacy. get an auto insurance quote. u.s.a.a. we know what it means to serve. [ male announcer ] in 2011, at&t is at work, building up our wireless network all across america. we're adding new cell sites... increasing network capacity, and investing billions of dollars to improve your wireless network experience.
has rolled straight into new york city. on her list of historical sites evidently includes trump tower where she met with the donald earlier this evening before the two headed out for pizza with trump's wife and palin's daughter piper. so far palin's all american road trip has fallen somewhere between a campaign swing and a nice family vacation. she says she wants to invite people to participate in all that is good about america but that invitation is lacking crucial information. her staff is not revealing the tour schedule to supporters, reporters, or even local gop officials. palin spent time in pennsylvania yesterday including a visit to gettysburg but the chairman of the pennsylvania republican party said i have had no contact with palin. i question the value of the theater by some candidates. now palin says she is not revealing her itinerary because she wants the media to figure it out by themselves. >> it would be a mistake for me
to become some kind of conventional politician and doing things the way that it's always been done with the media in terms of relationship with them, telling them to come along and we'll orchestrate this, strip this, and basically write a story for you about what we're doing every day. no. i want them to do a little work on a tour like this. the media can figure out where we're going if they do their investigative work or try to as you put it go crazy trying to figure it out. >> if you don't talk to them why find you? anyway, one thing we do know for sure palin made it clear that she is staying true to her drill baby drill mentality. here is her response to a question about whether all her bus tour events would be as loud as its rolling thunder kickoff. >> oh, it would be a blast if they were this loud and if they smelled this good. i love that smell of the emissions. >> he is convinced al qaeda is out to get him and believes guy activists want to fire bomb his office. who are we talking about? the delusional world of roger ailes coming up. "the ed show" made the wisconsin 14 famous back in february and
john nichols is going to be here to tell you why the infamous wisconsin six might make this a long, hot summer for scott walker. that's coming your way next. she felt lost... until the combination of three good probiotics in phillips' colon health defended against the bad gas, diarrhea and constipation. ...and? it helped balance her colon. oh, now that's the best part. i love your work. [ female announcer ] phillips' colon health. [ male announcer ] introducing mio. a revolutionary water enhancer. add a little...add a lot.
for a drink that's just the way you like it. make it yours. make it mio. my son and i never missed opening day. but with copd making it hard to breathe, i thought those days might be over. so my doctor prescribed symbicort. it helps significantly improve my lung function, starting within 5 minutes. symbicort doesn't replace a rescue inhaler for sudden symptoms. with symbicort, today i'm breathing better, and that means... game on! symbicort is for copd, including chronic bronchitis and emphysema. it should not be taken more than twice a day. symbicort may increase your risk of lung infections, osteoporosis, and some eye problems. tell your doctor if you have a heart condition or high blood pressure before taking it. [ whistle ] with copd, i thought i might miss out on my favorite tradition. now symbicort significantly improves my lung function, starting within 5 minutes. and that makes a difference in my breathing. today i'm back with my favorite team. ask your doctor about symbicort.
i got my first prescription free. call or click to learn more. [ male announcer ] if you can't afford your medication, astrazeneca may be able to help. so every year my family throws this great reunion in austin. but this year, i can only afford one trip and i've always wanted to learn how to surf. austin's great -- just not for surfing. so i checked out hotwire. and by booking with them, i saved enough to swing both trips. see, hotwire checks the competition's rates every day so they can guarantee their low prices. that's how i got a 4-star hotel on the beach in san diego for half price. ♪ h-o-t-w-i-r-e ♪ hotwire.com
hi everybody. welcome back to the ed show. i'm thomas roberts. it is going to be a sweltering political summer for governor scott walker and six wisconsin republican state senators. today the wisconsin government accountability board cleared the way for recall elections of three more republican senators who voted for governor walker's anti-labor bill. last week the board approved recall elections for dan kapanke, randy hopper, and luther olsen. today rob koules, alberta darling, and sheila harsdorf joined the list of wisconsin republicans who have to fight for their jobs this summer. the js online points out at no point in u.s. history have attempts been made to recall so many legislators at the same time over the same issue.
the government accountability board has yet to rule on the other recall petitions gathered on three democrats that were part of the wisconsin 14 who fled the state you may remember to temporarily hold up walker's bill earlier this year. the board was ordered to decide on all nine senators up for recount but was delayed by the enormous amount of petitions to oust the republicans in the recall election for the wisconsin supreme court. they are asking for an extension now to decide on the democrats next week. eric mcleod the attorney for the recalled republicans objected to the extension. >> i am surprised the board decided to proceed in light of the court's order that required all of the remaining six be considered together today. they seem unconcerned with the fact that the court required it and apparently intend to ask for forgiveness later. >> the board had been working under a plan to hold all recall elections coming up on july 12th but the delay could move the
elections now to later on in july. so for more on all of these stories we want to be asking the questions of john nichols, the washington correspondent for "the nation" and follows this really closely. john, it's good to have you back on. explain this distinction. why the distinction between the republicans and the petitions signed to recall the democrats? >> well, the democratic petitions were gathered by wisconsinites. mostly people from within the districts. these were grass roots campaigns, neighbors going to their neighbors, gathering the signatures and very one-on-one, traditional sense. the way most people would understand it. the republican petitions, the once seeking to displace some of the wisconsin 14, were gathered by folks from out of state. you had the state republican party hired a colorado firm to bring in petition gatherers and frankly those republican petitions are a mess. they've already had a number of names struck from them because of claims of fraud. you had one instance in
southeast wisconsin, the district of senator rob wurch where the name of a senior democratic legislator's father was on the petition to remove the democratic senator except the father had been dead for 20 years. so the government accountability board has a lot of work to do to just sort through very messy, very troubling petitions. >> when we talk about the government accountability board or the gab as a lot of people are going to hear it called, is this a bipartisan organization, john? >> yes, it is. the government accountability board is perhaps better understood as a nonpartisan organization. its board is actually a group of retired judges, people who have served on the bench honorably often for many years, taken retirement, and then were appointed to this board with an eye toward making sure that they're not political players. you don't have a bunch of former legislators or former elected officials from the partisan side. our judges in wisconsin despite
some of our recent races are elected on a nonpartisan basis and so the whole of the board comes from nonpartisan background. >> from all of your reporting on this do you think the gab is going to approve this recall of any of the democrats? >> yes. i think a couple of them will get through. ultimately they did over petition so they've got signatures but i want to emphasize especially the petitions against jim holperin the democratic senator in the far northern part of the state, there is a lot of trouble with those petitions, a lot of concerns about people who were frankly encouraged to sign using fraudulent methods. >> john, explain when you expect to see these recalls. i imagine since this is dragging on it's got to be embarrassing for people and authority leaders in wisconsin to see this going through such stages of -- i don't know -- taking the democratic system through such mud. >> well, wisconsin is a dot your
is cross your ts sort of state. they like to get things right. people are relatively patient with this process but you're right it is getting a little complicated. one of the big problems here is that you could separate these recall elections. you could have the republican senators who are up for recall placed on the ballot say july 12th or july 19th and then have the democrats placed on a little bit later but the two parties are really wrangling over that. in the end, that's going to be the sort of trip wire is can you keep all of these recalls on the same day? that's what the government accountability board is doing but it's getting very, very difficult because of different quality of these petitions. >> last but not least, in the state supreme court election, joann kloppenberg conceded to david prosser today. is that going to help the governor walker and the republicans in any way? >> i don't think so. i mean, david prosser did have a
lead. he had been seen as the victor by an awful lot of folks. joann kloppenberg's question was whether she wanted to pursue a legal challenge raising some of the issues as regards the voting practices particularly in waukesha county. she chose not to pursue that. but really the truth is the focus in wisconsin right now is on these recall elections. and i think that's where the energy is going to be. >> john nichols of "the nation" magazine great to see you tonight. thanks. scott walker is pretty unpopular in wisconsin but apparently is not alone in this country. new polls suggesting buyer's remorse in several states that elected republican governors last year. we'll bring you more coming up next. [ male announcer ] lockable waterproof storage. there's only one full-size pickup that's got it. let me give you a hint. it's called rambox. [ horse snorts ]
guts. glory. ram. new york congressman anthony weiner has hired a lawyer to look into possible legal action after a lewd picture was allegedly sent from his twitter account to a 21-year-old student in seattle. he says someone hacked into his account and sent the photo as a prank though he has not yet
asked law enforcement to investigate it. the alleged recipient seems to back up the claim saying although she is a fan of the congressman's and although he follows her on twitter she had never met or spoken to him before saying, quote, there have never been any inappropriate exchanges between anthony weiner and myself including the tweet/picture in question which had apparently been deleted before it reached me. weiner said today he is done talking about the story calling it a distraction from issues that he cares about. strangely enough, though, canadian politician is wrapped up in this same type of story. listen to this. but more revealing, a photograph that uploaded to george lep's twitter account over the weekend. he says the picture was posted after someone stole his blackberry. up next, some union busting republican governors have more than twitter hackers to actually worry about. voters in wisconsin, ohio, florida just some of the states that are having serious buyer's remorse. one of the largest oils in the world. a large part of that is oil sands.
this resource has the ability to create hundreds of thousands of jobs. at our kearl project in canada, we'll be able to produce these oil sands with the same emissions as many other oils and that's a huge breakthrough. that's good for our country's energy security and our economy. down the hill? man: all right. we were actually thinking, maybe... we're going to hike up here, so we'll catch up with you guys. [ indistinct talking and laughter ] whew! i think it's worth it. working with a partner you can trust is always a good decision. massmutual. let our financial professionals help you reach your goals.
scott walker who won by six points in november would lose to his opponent tom barret by seven points if a do-over election were held today. ohio governor john kasich won with a two-point margin. today he would lose by a whopping 25 points. republican governors from michigan, pennsylvania, iowa, and georgia would suffer the same fats according to this polling. only nevada governor ryan sandoval would still win his race with a rematch. as for the flore governor he would take a 20-point tumble this time around. it is a hypothetical outcome that has the attention of the white house. political reports that president obama's campaign team plans to make the unpopular governor the center piece of the president's re-election strategy when it comes to dealing with the sunshine state. let's bring in our guest, the president of momentum analysis, a democratic polling agency. margie, good to have you on tonight. let's get straight to this and dive in because it is
interesting to see these numbers especially with some of these whoppers of 20, 25 points, a loss today. where did these republican governors lose the most ground just over seven months? >> well, it's interesting. there's a few things that are really important here and one of the most important things from these polls is that independents are now saying that they're going to vote democratic. in the actual elections according to official exit poll results they voted for republicans. independents went republicans but for the republican candidate. but now they're voting for the democratic candidate. this kind of pattern is what we saw in 2006 when democrats took back the house. we saw independents moving toward democrats and in 2010 we saw independents moving toward republicans. to see independents now shift again toward democrats is really encouraging. >> do you think that this buyer's remorse would extend to republicans in federal government and does that mean republicans are in danger of losing the house in 2012? >> i absolutely think that what we see from these polls and a
lot of other polls and what we saw in new york, the new york congressional contest last week is that there is buyer's remorse not just in washington but in the states. and, you know, i get it. people saw -- people heard what might happen during the campaign and said, you know, of course republicans aren't going to end medicare as we know it or try and take back child safety laws and take on teachers while giving tax breaks to giveaways to oil companies and to corporations. i mean, who would do such a thing? in fact, that is what they did immediately. those are the actions people have been taking republicans in washington and across the country and a lot of state legislators and people have immediately decided this is not for us. >> margie, you talk about washington. president obama, though, is enjoying this bump in an approval rating. do you think this rebound correlates to the declining numbers that we're seeing across this country for republican governors or do you think it's just still riding that wave of getting rid of bin laden?
>> i think there are a few things. i think, one, people are getting a real close look at what republicans -- what the republican agenda is and deciding it's terrible. i mean the hangover was big last weekend but what's a bigger hangover is after the republican takeover from 2010. and the ryan plan is really a disaster for republicans from a message strategy, message point of view, from what voters want to hear. you know, it cost them a safe congressional seat what should have been a safe seat and it's going to cause them huge problems down the road. >> what do you make though of the reported strategy of the obama re-election campaign to highlight these unpopular governors specifically that of rick scott in florida? >> these, all of these states are really crucial swing states. ohio, pennsylvania, florida. michigan, wisconsin, and iowa. these are all swing states that -- and georgia. >> right. >> these are states that have been in play.
they've been battleground states and the fact that there are these republican governors who had no thoughts of good will, no benefit of the doubt, no honeymoon, just immediately were rejected by their own voters and by independents as something that is going to benefit not just the obama re-election campaign but any other campaign -- democratic candidate running for congress or senate or a state representative or a down ballot statewide. >> how are republicans reacting to these polls, digesting them? are they going to have to alter their agendas over the next year and a half? is that really enough time? >> i don't know. they seem to still have this kid in the candy store kind of attitude where they're not really looking at what the voters think because if they had been they wouldn't be in this situation. they wouldn't be doing exactly the opposite of what the american people say they want. the american people don't want to end heating oil help for low income seniors. they don't want to take away mandatory maternity care coverage. they don't want to, you know, take away health care from children yet these are the kinds of things. they don't want to redefine rape.
these are the kinds of things republicans have decided was their first number one priority instead of working to create jobs for the working class. that is what the american people really want. >> margie, nice to have you on tonight. thanks. >> thank you. >> loyalists call him the chairman. now the man who runs fox news. we're talking roger ailes. at 190 miles per hour, the wind will literally lift ordinary windshield wipers off the glass. so, did we build a slower car? or design wipers that could handle anything? what do you think? the cadillac cts-v, the world's fastest production sedan.
we don't just make luxury cars, we make cadillacs the two trains and a bus rider. the "i'll sleep when it's done" academic. for 80 years, we've been inspired by you. and we've been honored to walk with you to help you get where you want to be. ♪ because your moment is now. let nothing stand in your way. learn more at keller.edu. [ male announcer ] in 2011, at&t is at work, building up our wireless network all across america. we're adding new cell sites... increasing network capacity, and investing billions of dollars to improve your wireless network experience. from a single phone call to the most advanced data download, we're covering more people in more places than ever before
yeah. well we're the two active ingredients in zegerid otc. i'm omeprazole. and i'm sodium bicarbonate. just one pill a day ... gives you 24-hour relief. & one mission. two ingredients heartburn solved. so he is described as a cross between don rickles and don corleone, a commanding, right wing operative determined to take down the left and does it all with the help of a highly profitable network he runs, fox news. the latest profile from "rolling
stone" magazine gives new insight into the man simply known as the chairman. roger ailes. in a moment the writer of that profile tim dickinson is going to join me. ailes is the master though at knowing his fox news audience and playing into their fears. but as dickinson writes ailes is also deeply paranoid and fearful himself. when ailes first moved into his office at fox news headquarters here in new york he believed that gay activists would fire bomb it. he demanded, quote, bomb proof glass installed in his office windows. even going so far as to personally inspect samples of high tech, plexiglas. ailes is also convinced he's been personally targeted by al qaeda, quote. he surrounds himself with an aggressive security detail and is licensed to carry a concealed hand gun. you know they're coming to get me he tells friends inside his blast resistant office at fox news headquarters. he keeps a monitor on his desk that allows him to view activity outside his closed door.
once after observing a dark skinned man in what ailes perceived to be muslim garb he put fox news on lockdown. the suspected terrorist turned out to be a janitor. joining me now is the national affairs correspondent for "rolling stone" tim dickinson. nice to have you with us. his article how roger ailes built the fox news fear factory appears in the current issue of "rolling stone" available on news stands. why is ailes convinced he is the target of these groups basically gay terrorists and al qaeda? >> i can't get too deeply into roger ailes' head. i don't know what underlies these preoccupations of his. you hear them from multiple different sources and they seem to be true. he surrounds himself by traveling with him apparently is like an episode of 24. he's got this big black suv and guys who deliver the package from the car to the office headquarters. but i think we can get distracted by some of these jucier details from sort of the broader sweep of ailes' life
which goes straight from nixon through reagan through the first bush and then he sort of goes under ground. >> right. >> and is working for big tobacco trying to take down hillary care and then right into fox news. roger ailes has always said that he has had a break between his two lives. his life as a politico and his life as a broadcast executive. and i think the main takeaway from my piece is that that is a fiction and a lie he has told the american people. he's told congress. there is this dramatic through line where everything he wanted to do as an operative with richard nixon in 1968 he is doing now 24/7 on his political network. >> speaking of that, i can't speak to al qaeda but i can speak to the gays. i know they're in his newsroom and on his air but you're right fox news stands as the culmination of everything ailes tried to do for his old boss richard nixon who you brought up. is his ultimate goal to destroy president obama and does he believe he can achieve that goal? >> i think roger ailes if you punch him full of sodium
pentathol, he views it as he is trying to save the country from barack obama. if you talk to the white house they'll tell you in their conversations with him he's bringing up -- as sort of the demented view you get of the administration on fox news is roger ailes' view that the darker interpretations of what the obama administration is doing, he believes those. those aren't contrived in his mind. he views himself as sort of someone who is trying to save america from this terrible president. i think he thinks he can do it. he really, it's under appreciated but fox has this sort of whip function with the gop and he can, when you have this 24/7 megaphone you can really bring people into line and help shape the agenda in a very powerful way. raise money for candidates and get people elected. look at john kasich the former fox news host who is now the union busting governor of ohio. >> a great point. he really is the first candidate
of the fox news party, the new governor of ohio. but voters won a do-over in ohio. none of the pundits ailes recruited are polling well against obama right now. do you think viewers can catch on to the ailes strategy here? >> you know, i think if huckabee had entered the race it would have changed the situation dramatically so i think the strategy there, he gave huckabee a show, sort of a throw away according to my source and huckabee took to it and has taken to the life of a tv star rather than a political candidate but if huckabee had joinld the race joined the race we'd be having a very different conversation and sarah palin is still the elephant in the wings. >> narrator: the tour bus right now. >> exactly. with donald trump at trump tower. >> when you are researching for this article what surprised you the most, the most eyebrow raising for you? >> i was someone who never was really too troubled by what fox news appeared to be.
i thought there is room in the media landscape for left wing and right wing media but what i was really shocked was the totality of what they were doing, the active collaboration with the republican party, the talking points that come out of mitch mcconnell's mouth. >> right. >> on the same day they come out of sean hannity's mouth. as the former media critic of fox news told me, the question is no longer whether fox news is an arm of the republican party but whether it's become the torso instead. so this is, you know, a 24/7 propaganda outlet for the republican party but it's unclear who the boss is. you know, it seems the chairman is the boss. >> real quickly i have about five seconds. does fox news survive if roger ailes isn't there? >> that's a good question, an open question. it's hard -- to see who would have the same skill set and the same political juice that roger ailes would. i think it will continue certainly as a successful tv program. but whether it will have that same political juice it would be hard to say. >> all r